InsightsCorporate

Bank loan claim in Cyprus: why the company’s defences failed

In short

A company, its guarantors and their mortgages lost a €1 million bank claim on appeal. Every defence failed for the same reason: nothing was proved to back it.

Klitos Platis, advocate

Your first message costs nothing: within one working day we tell you whether we can help and what it would cost.

klitos@kleanthousplatis.com

In June 2012 the Bank of Cyprus lent a company €970,000. On the same day a second company and an individual guaranteed the loan, and three mortgages were registered at the Larnaca Land Registry, one by the borrower and two by the individual guarantor. The bank terminated the loan in July 2013 and sued. The loans were later transferred to Gordian Holdings Limited, which took over the claim.

The District Court gave judgment for €1,026,535.96 plus interest, and ordered the sale of the borrower’s mortgaged property. On 30 October 2026 the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal in Pico Trading Ltd v. Gordian Holdings Ltd, with €5,100 in costs plus VAT.

Four defences, one weakness

None of the defences was backed by evidence, and the borrowers called no witness at trial. They argued four things on appeal:

  • the bank’s statements did not prove the balance;
  • the mortgages were void from the start;
  • the loan had never been properly terminated;
  • the two companies had signed outside their objects and without valid board decisions.

The Court of Appeal took each in turn, and each failed.

The bank’s statements were enough

A copy of the bank’s books is prima facie proof of the balance once a bank officer lays the foundation. Section 22 of the Evidence Law, Cap. 9, requires proof that the book is one of the bank’s ordinary books, that entries were made in the ordinary course of business, that it is in the bank’s custody, and that the copy was compared with the original and found correct.

The bank’s officer gave that evidence and said he had compared the printed statements with the book himself. The borrowers argued that he had no personal knowledge of the account throughout its life. The court rejected that: the person who checked the copy is the right witness, and requiring someone who handled the account at every stage would be excessive.

The evidence then shifted the burden to the borrowers to show the balance was wrong. They had not pleaded any error in their defence, had not put one to the bank’s witness, and called no evidence. The presumption stood. Section 35 of Cap. 9, the court added, matters only if the admissibility of the statement is objected to, and here it was not.

The mortgages were valid

A mortgage that states the maximum secured sum and the interest complies with section 21 of Law 9/1965, even if costs are not fixed in advance. The borrowers argued that the interest was not specified, that the mortgages secured costs beyond what the law allows, and that they breached the equitable right of redemption.

Identical arguments, the court noted, had been raised by the same advocate in earlier appeals and rejected. Costs of recovery are added to the secured sum as accepted banking practice and cannot be fixed beforehand. The right of redemption is a separate point that must be pleaded on its own. On the facts it was hollow anyway: after the borrowers made an offer during the trial, the bank released two of the three mortgages.

Termination letters and the objects clause

A letter properly addressed and posted, and not returned, is prima facie proof that it arrived. The bank officer described preparing, signing and handing the termination letters for posting to the addresses in the agreements. Cross-examination on the point was vague and no one said the letters never came.

A company cannot escape a loan or guarantee by pointing to its objects unless it proves the bank knew. Section 33A of the Companies Law, Cap. 113, binds a company to its officers’ acts even outside its objects. The exception applies only if the company proves that the third party knew the act was outside the objects, or could not have been unaware of it, and publication of the memorandum and articles does not by itself prove knowledge. Limits that the articles or a board or general meeting place on officers’ powers cannot be raised against third parties at all.

Here the companies did not even produce their articles, while the bank produced board resolutions approving the agreements and mortgages. The point was left, in the court’s words, unsupported and unproved.

Against a bank that proves its books, a defence that is not pleaded, put to the witness and supported by evidence goes nowhere.

What this means in practice

For a director, a company guarantee or mortgage given for someone else’s loan will almost always bind the company. Section 33A protects the lender. If the company should not be giving security, the time to say so is before the board resolution is signed, not in the defence.

For a borrower or guarantor who is sued, a defence has to be built on facts, not on general objections. If the balance is wrong, plead the specific error, put it to the bank’s witness and call evidence of it, such as your own payment records or an accountant’s reconciliation. Arguments that the mortgage is void for unfixed interest or costs have now failed repeatedly in the Court of Appeal, and running them again mainly adds costs.

An offer can achieve more than a defence. Here a concrete offer during the trial led the bank to release two of the three mortgages. A debtor facing a well-documented claim should consider negotiation early, while there is still something to trade.

For creditors and portfolio buyers, the decision confirms that one officer who checked the records can prove the debt. The witness does not need to have managed the account from the beginning.

Our corporate and commercial team advises boards before they give security, and our banking disputes practice acts for borrowers, guarantors and creditors when a loan claim reaches court.

A guarantee signed by a board is a commitment of the company, and the objects clause will not undo it.

Questions we are asked

Can a Cyprus company avoid a loan or guarantee by saying it was outside its objects?

Rarely. Under section 33A of the Companies Law, Cap. 113, a company is bound by the acts of its officers even where they fall outside its objects, unless the company proves that the bank knew, or could not have been unaware, that they did. Publication of the memorandum and articles is not enough on its own. In Pico Trading Ltd v. Gordian Holdings Ltd (30 October 2026) the companies did not even produce their articles, and the defence failed.

Does the bank’s witness need to have handled the account from the start?

No. Under section 22 of the Evidence Law, Cap. 9, a copy of a bank book entry is prima facie evidence once a bank officer proves the book is an ordinary book of the bank, kept in the ordinary course, and that the copy was checked against it. The Court of Appeal held that the officer who made the check is the right witness, whether or not he dealt with the account at every stage.

Is a mortgage void because the interest rate or the costs are not fixed in it?

Not on that ground alone. The Court of Appeal followed its recent decisions that a mortgage stating the maximum secured sum and interest, with costs that can be determined, complies with section 21 of Law 9/1965. Costs of recovery are added as accepted banking practice.

Sources

Klitos Platis

Klitos Platis

Advocate, Partner

Kleanthous & Platis LLC, Cyprus
Published 14 November 2026

Need advice on your own matter?

Your first message costs nothing: within one working day we tell you whether we can help and what it would cost.

Email Klitos Platis
WhatsAppEnquiry form

klitos@kleanthousplatis.com

Kleanthous & Platis LLC Registered law company Cyprus Bar Association HE 441973

Further reading

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and their application can change, and individual circumstances differ. For advice on your own matter, contact Klitos Platis at klitos@kleanthousplatis.com.

Receive legal updates by email

When Cyprus law changes, hear it from us

One short email when something changes that matters: new legislation, a decision worth knowing, a deadline. Written by the partners, no marketing, unsubscribe with one click.

You are on the list. The next update on Cyprus law will reach your inbox.

That did not go through. Please write to office@kleanthousplatis.com and we will add you.

Your address is used for these updates and nothing else. Privacy notice.