A sister lent her brother CY£10,000 by cheque and sued his estate after his death. The Supreme Court upheld €17,986: the cashed cheque made the claim probable under Cap. 9.
Your first message costs nothing: within one working day we tell you whether we can help and what it would cost.
klitos@kleanthousplatis.com
On 8 May 2002 a woman lent her brother CY£10,000, repayable on demand. She paid it by a Bank of Cyprus cheque dated the same day, and he cashed it. When she later asked for the money he did not pay, and he died without paying. His son was appointed administrator of the estate and did not respond to her demand either.
She sued the estate in the District Court of Nicosia in action 1673/2011 and obtained judgment for €17,986.01 plus interest and costs. On 17 November 2026 the Supreme Court dismissed the administrator’s appeal in Prastitis v. Venediktou, with €2,400 in costs plus VAT against the estate.
The special rule for claims against an estate
A claim against a dead person’s estate is looked at with suspicion, because the debtor cannot answer it. Section 7 of the Evidence Law, Cap. 9, puts that into law for claims based on a debt or a gift.
Such a claim is not accepted on the uncorroborated evidence of the person making it. It succeeds only if circumstances appear or are proved that make the claim probable from the outset, or that shift to the deceased’s representatives the burden of disproving it. The trial court applied section 7 of its own motion, although neither side had raised it, citing Markou v. Provident Fund (2015).
Why the cheque mattered
The cashed cheque was strong evidence that the money passed, though not proof of a loan. The trial court said in terms that issuing and handing over a cheque does not by itself prove an agreement to lend.
What the cheque did was make the sister’s claim probable from the outset, which is what section 7 requires. It was never put to her in cross-examination that the cheque was not given to her brother or that he did not cash it. Nor did the administrator suggest that it was she who owed her brother money. The trial court also noted that she had said her brother’s wife knew of the loan, which left the estate free to call the widow to contradict her. It did not.
The administrator’s evidence could not fill the gap. The son, a bank employee to whom his father turned for financial advice, said his father had never mentioned any debt, and that he learned of the claim only when the action was served, 18 months after the death. The trial court found that his evidence showed ignorance of the facts and could not help on whether the loan existed. On appeal he argued that the court had shifted the burden of proof to him. The Supreme Court disagreed: the trial court had approached the sister’s evidence with care, found her credible, and held that she proved the loan on the balance of probabilities.
Section 7 does not bar a claim against an estate. It asks for something beyond the claimant’s word that makes the claim probable, and a cashed cheque can be that thing.
The point the estate could not take
Limitation was not pleaded, so it could not be argued on appeal. The loan dated from 2002 and the action from 2011. The administrator’s counsel abandoned a limitation argument at the hearing of the appeal.
The Supreme Court said that choice was correct, because limitation had not been raised in the pleadings or at any point at trial, citing Fesa v. Kasapi (1994). Whether a limitation defence would have succeeded was never decided.
What this means in practice
If you lend money to a family member, record it so the record outlives the borrower. A bank transfer or cheque shows the money moved. A short signed note that it is a loan, the amount and when it is repayable, shows why. Without the note, the lender’s case after a death rests on section 7 of Cap. 9 and on the court believing the lender.
If you are a lender and the borrower has died, act against the administrator or executor. The claim is brought against the estate through its personal representative, and it should be brought promptly. Three things help:
- the bank record of the payment, and any message or email in which the borrower acknowledged the debt;
- a written demand to the administrator, sent as soon as one is appointed;
- the names of people the borrower told about the loan, who can be called to give evidence.
If you are an administrator facing such a claim, plead every defence at the start. The estate here could not rely on limitation because it was never pleaded. Saying that the deceased never mentioned a debt is not a defence. Calling witnesses who knew the deceased’s affairs, and testing the claimant on the documents, is.
Our litigation team acts for creditors and for administrators in claims against estates, and our page on contested estates in Cyprus explains how these disputes run alongside the administration.
The cheque proves the money moved. A one-line note that it was a loan proves the rest, and it is the line most family lenders never write.
Questions we are asked
Can I recover a loan from the estate of a relative who has died in Cyprus?
Yes, by suing the administrator or executor of the estate. Section 7 of the Evidence Law, Cap. 9, adds a hurdle: a claim against an estate based on a debt or a gift is not accepted on the claimant’s uncorroborated evidence, unless circumstances make it probable from the outset or shift the burden to the estate. In Prastitis v. Venediktou (17 November 2026) the Supreme Court upheld judgment for a sister who had lent her brother CY£10,000 by a bank cheque he cashed.
Is a cheque enough to prove a loan?
Not on its own. The trial court said, and the Supreme Court accepted, that issuing a cheque does not by itself prove an agreement to lend. It is, however, strong evidence that the money passed, and in this case it was enough to make the claim probable under section 7 of Cap. 9. The court then believed the sister’s account of the loan, which the administrator could not contradict.
Can the estate raise limitation for the first time on appeal?
No. In Prastitis the administrator’s counsel abandoned a limitation argument on appeal, and the Supreme Court noted that limitation had not been pleaded or raised at trial. A defence that is not pleaded is, as a rule, not available on appeal.
Sources
- Giorgos Prastitis, as administrator of the estate of Foivos Prastitis v. Lenia Venediktou, Civil Appeal 397/2016, Supreme Court, 17 November 2026
- The Evidence Law, Cap. 9, consolidated text, section 7, CyLaw

Need advice on your own matter?
Your first message costs nothing: within one working day we tell you whether we can help and what it would cost.
klitos@kleanthousplatis.com
Kleanthous & Platis LLC Registered law company Cyprus Bar Association HE 441973
Further reading
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and their application can change, and individual circumstances differ. For advice on your own matter, contact Klitos Platis at klitos@kleanthousplatis.com.
Receive legal updates by email
When Cyprus law changes, hear it from us
One short email when something changes that matters: new legislation, a decision worth knowing, a deadline. Written by the partners, no marketing, unsubscribe with one click.
You are on the list. The next update on Cyprus law will reach your inbox.
That did not go through. Please write to office@kleanthousplatis.com and we will add you.
Your address is used for these updates and nothing else. Privacy notice.